Switching marine salt might sound simple — just open a new bucket and mix, right? Unfortunately, for reef keepers, it’s not always that easy. Changing salt brands can cause unexpected shifts in water chemistry, stress corals, or even crash a tank if done carelessly.
The good news? With the right strategy, you can change marine salt safely — whether you’re upgrading to a premium reef mix, trying a new formulation, or solving water chemistry issues. In this guide, we’ll walk you through exactly how to do it, step by step.
Why You Might Want to Switch Marine Salt
Even experienced aquarists occasionally decide to switch salt brands. Here are the most common reasons:
-
Better water chemistry: Different salts offer different levels of calcium, magnesium, alkalinity, and trace elements.
-
Improved coral growth: Premium reef salts often support faster skeletal development and more vibrant colours.
-
Fewer impurities: Some salts mix cleaner, dissolve faster, and leave less residue.
-
Tank evolution: As your system matures — from fish-only to mixed reef, for example — your salt needs may change.
-
Cost or availability: Pricing, local supply, or brand discontinuation might also prompt a switch.
Whattever your reason, understanding the potential risks will help you avoid problems.
The Risks of Switching Too Quickly
Marine salt is more than just sodium chloride — it’s a carefully balanced mix of elements designed to recreate natural seawater. Each brand uses slightly different concentrations of these elements, which means sudden changes can lead to:
-
Alkalinity swings: A rapid rise or drop can shock corals and stress invertebrates.
-
Calcium & magnesium imbalance: Incorrect ratios can inhibit coral growth or cause precipitation.
-
Bacterial disruption: A sudden shift in chemistry can impact your biological filter.
-
Coral stress: Many corals react to sudden parameter changes with polyp retraction, colour fading, or tissue recession.
The good news? All of these risks are easy to avoid with a controlled, gradual transition.
Step-by-Step: How to Switch Marine Salt Safely
Follow this process to change salt brands without upsetting your system’s delicate balance:
1. Test Your Current Parameters
Before introducing a new salt, test your aquarium’s water for:
-
Salinity (target ~1.025 / 35 ppt)
-
Alkalinity (target 7–10 dKH)
-
Calcium (target 420–450 ppm)
-
Magnesium (target 1250–1350 ppm)
-
pH (target 8.1–8.4)
Knowing your baseline helps you compare the new salt’s parameters and plan the transition.
2. Blend the New Salt Gradually
The golden rule: never switch 100% of your salt mix in one water change. Instead, phase it in slowly:
-
First 2–3 water changes: Use ~25% new salt and 75% old salt.
-
Next 2–3 water changes: Increase to ~50/50.
-
Final 2 water changes: Move to 100% new salt.
This slow introduction gives your system time to adapt to the new chemistry and reduces the risk of parameter swings.
3. Monitor Water Chemistry Closely
Test water parameters after every water change during the transition. Keep an eye out for:
-
Sudden changes in alkalinity or pH
-
Coral behaviour changes (e.g. closed polyps, bleaching)
-
Calcium or magnesium precipitation
If anything seems unstable, pause at your current blend ratio and continue water changes until parameters stabilise before increasing the proportion of new salt.
4. Match Conditions for Each Water Change
To reduce stress, always ensure your new saltwater matches your tank’s current conditions as closely as possible:
-
Temperature: Match within ±1°C
-
Salinity: Match within ±0.001 SG
-
pH: Keep within ±0.1
-
Element levels: Aim for a gradual change, not a sharp jump
Small, regular changes are much safer than large water changes with different chemistry.
5. Consider a Transition Buffer
Some aquarists use a short-term stabiliser or buffer (like a balanced alkalinity supplement) during the switch to smooth out fluctuations. This is optional, but it can help if the two salts differ significantly in composition.
Tips for a Smooth Salt Transition
-
Mix thoroughly: Always dissolve salt fully before use to avoid concentrated “hot spots.”
-
Keep water changes small: Frequent 10–15% changes are safer than infrequent large ones.
-
Stir the salt bucket: Minerals can settle — mix the dry salt before measuring.
-
Avoid other major changes: Don’t add new livestock, upgrade equipment, or change lighting during a salt transition.
-
Record results: Tracking your parameters with each change helps you fine-tune future water chemistry.
What If Problems Occur?
If you notice coral stress, cloudy water, or parameter spikes:
-
Pause the transition — continue with the current salt mix ratio until stability returns.
-
Perform smaller, more frequent water changes.
-
Re-test your source water, mixing technique, and dosing schedule for errors.
In most cases, stability returns within a week or two once the system adjusts.
Final Thoughts
Switching marine salt brands doesn’t have to be stressful — and it’s often a smart move for improving water chemistry, coral growth, or overall tank health. The key is to make the change gradually, test frequently, and monitor your livestock closely during the transition.
With a little planning, you’ll enjoy the benefits of your new salt without any of the risks — and your reef will reward you with better stability, growth, and colour.
Ready to Try a New Marine Salt?
At Charterhouse Aquatics, we stock a full range of premium marine salts from trusted brands — including reef-specific, pro-grade, and high-purity blends designed to support every type of system. Whether you’re running a fish-only tank or a thriving SPS reef, you’ll find the perfect salt for your next chapter in reefkeeping.
